If you’re planning to build a pergola in Farmington or anywhere in Davis County, one of the first decisions you’ll face is material: wood or vinyl? It’s not just about aesthetics—Utah’s dry summers, snowy winters, and elevation swings put outdoor structures to the test. At Farmington Landscaping, we’ve installed both options for years, and here’s our no-nonsense breakdown to help you choose the right fit.
1. Aesthetic and Curb Appeal
Wood Pergolas
- Rich, natural texture that feels timeless
- Can be stained or painted to match your home
- Great for rustic, craftsman, or traditional designs
Vinyl Pergolas
- Sleek, clean look with minimal maintenance
- Limited color options (usually white or tan)
- Pairs well with modern or minimalist homes
Verdict: Wood wins if you want full design flexibility and warm curb appeal. Vinyl wins for a clean, uniform finish.
2. Durability in Utah’s Seasons
Wood Pergolas
- Susceptible to warping, cracking, and fading
- Needs sealing or staining every 2–3 years
- Can hold up well if maintained properly
Vinyl Pergolas
- Weather-resistant and won’t crack or peel
- Immune to rot, termites, and most environmental stress
- Can turn brittle in extreme cold over time
Verdict: Vinyl wins for low-maintenance durability, especially in snowy or wet zones.
3. Maintenance Requirements
Wood Pergolas
- Requires regular care: sealants, paint touch-ups, sanding
- Can be repaired easily if damaged
Vinyl Pergolas
- Virtually maintenance-free
- Occasional hose-down or wipe is enough
Verdict: Vinyl is the clear winner for homeowners who want a “set it and forget it” structure.
4. Cost Comparison
Wood Pergolas
- More affordable up front
- Installation is straightforward
- Long-term costs higher due to maintenance
Vinyl Pergolas
- Higher initial price
- Pays off over time with minimal upkeep
Verdict: Wood is better for short-term budgets. Vinyl is the better investment long-term.
5. What Works Best in Utah’s Climate?
Farmington homeowners deal with:
- Dry summer heat that fades paint and stains
- Freeze-thaw cycles that crack untreated lumber
- UV exposure that damages unprotected surfaces
In this climate, vinyl pergolas often outlast their wood counterparts, especially for homeowners who prefer a lower-maintenance lifestyle. But for those who want a custom look or are open to regular upkeep, wood still has a strong place—especially with cedar or redwood.
Let’s Build the Right Pergola for You
Not sure which way to go? We’ll help you compare costs, styles, and performance based on your space and goals. Whether you’re building shade over a patio or a statement piece for your backyard, Farmington Landscaping brings professional installation and honest advice.
📞 Call (###) ###-#### or schedule a site visit today